Journal Policies
- Research Misconduct Policy (Journal Policies · path: research-misconduct)
- Conflict of Interest (Journal Policies · path: conflict-of-interest)
- Post-Publication Discussion (Journal Policies · path: post-publication-discussion)
- Correction and Retraction (Journal Policies · path: correction-retraction)
- Peer Review Process (Journal Policies · path: peer-review)
SWAGATI: Journal of Community Service takes every allegation of research and publication misconduct seriously. The editor is responsible for protecting the accuracy and integrity of the published record. Allegations are handled fairly and objectively, following the flowcharts of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).
What counts as misconduct
- Fabrication or falsification of data or program results;
- Plagiarism, including self-plagiarism and a similarity score above 30% (Turnitin);
- Duplicate or simultaneous submission to another journal;
- Improper authorship (honorary, gift, or ghost authorship);
- Citation manipulation or manipulation of the peer review process;
- Undisclosed conflicts of interest;
- Activities involving community members without their consent.
How to report
Anyone (readers, reviewers, authors, or community partners) can report a suspected case by email to swagati@amikom.ac.id. The report should include the article title, a description of the concern, and any supporting evidence. The identity of the reporter is kept confidential.
Handling procedure
- Initial check. The editor checks whether the report concerns publication misconduct and whether the person reporting has a conflict of interest.
- Contacting the authors. If there are signs of misconduct, the editor contacts the corresponding author and asks for a full explanation on behalf of all authors, normally within 14 days.
- Investigation. The editor reviews the explanation and may ask for the original data, ask additional reviewers, or consult experts.
- Institution. If the explanation is not satisfactory, the editor informs the authors' institution and asks it to investigate.
- Decision. The Editor-in-Chief decides on the outcome, in proportion to the findings.
Possible outcomes
- If the concern is not supported: the case is closed, or the authors are asked to clarify or revise the manuscript.
- Before publication: the manuscript is rejected, and the authors may be barred from submitting for a period of time.
- After publication: a correction, an expression of concern, or a retraction linked to the original article is published, following the Correction and Retraction policy.
A conflict of interest exists when a financial, professional, academic, personal, or institutional relationship could influence, or appear to influence, the work or the decisions made about it. SWAGATI: Journal of Community Service requires everyone involved in the publication process to disclose actual and potential conflicts, so that every manuscript is evaluated fairly and objectively.
Types of conflict of interest
- Financial – funding, employment, consultancy, shares, honoraria, or paid partnerships related to the program;
- Professional and academic – close collaboration, supervision, or competition with the authors;
- Personal – family relationships or close friendships;
- Institutional – working at the same institution as the authors, or a relationship between the institution and the community partner or funder.
Authors
Authors must disclose all sources of funding for the community service program and any relationship that could affect the work. The disclosure is written in a Conflict of Interest statement at the end of the manuscript. If there is none, authors should write: “The authors declare no conflict of interest.”
Reviewers
Reviewers must decline an invitation, or inform the editor, if they have a conflict of interest with the authors, their institution, the community partner, or the funder, or if they can identify the authors.
Editors
An editor who has a conflict of interest with a manuscript (for example, as a co-author, colleague, or supervisor) must not take part in decisions about it. The journal assigns an independent editor or reviewer instead. Manuscripts submitted by members of the editorial team go through the same peer review process as other manuscripts.
Handling undisclosed conflicts
Reported conflicts are handled proportionately and transparently. Failure to disclose a relevant conflict may lead to an investigation under the Research Misconduct Policy and, depending on its seriousness, to a correction or retraction.
SWAGATI: Journal of Community Service welcomes discussion of published articles. Post-publication discussion helps correct errors that were missed during peer review, encourages constructive debate and alternative views, and keeps authors, editors, and the publisher accountable. The policy follows the guidance of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).
What can be raised
- Scientific or methodological issues – conclusions that are not supported by the data, weak evaluation methods, statistical errors, or insufficient detail to replicate the program;
- Technical errors – wrong numbers, tables, figures, or formulas, and missing or incorrect references;
- Ethical concerns – which are handled under the Research Misconduct Policy.
How to submit a comment
- Send the comment by email to swagati@amikom.ac.id with the subject “Post-Publication Discussion”, stating the article title, volume, and issue.
- Comments must be relevant, polite, and supported by evidence or references. Personal attacks are not accepted.
Process
- The editor reviews the comment for relevance and substance.
- Relevant comments are forwarded to the corresponding author, who is invited to respond within 30 days.
- The editor may publish the comment and the author's response as a Letter to the Editor in a following issue, or on the journal website.
Possible outcomes
Depending on what the discussion shows, the editor may publish a Corrigendum (correction), an Expression of Concern, or a Retraction if the main findings are no longer valid, following the Correction and Retraction policy.
SWAGATI: Journal of Community Service is committed to keeping the published record complete and accurate. Once an article has been published, it is changed only in the situations described below. This policy follows the COPE Retraction Guidelines and the national journal accreditation guidelines.
Withdrawal (before publication)
Authors may withdraw a manuscript only while it is under review, revision, or copyediting, and only for strong reasons. The corresponding author sends a Manuscript Withdrawal Form signed by all authors to the editorial office. The withdrawal is complete only after the editor confirms it. Once an article has been published, it cannot be withdrawn; it can only be corrected or retracted.
Erratum
An erratum is published when the journal makes an error during production that affects the article, such as an error in an author name, affiliation, table, figure, or page number. Minor spelling or grammar errors that do not affect the meaning are not corrected.
Corrigendum
A corrigendum is published when the authors find an error in their own work that does not change the main findings or conclusions, such as an error in data, an evaluation instrument, or a reference. The corresponding author contacts the editor, who decides whether a corrigendum is needed and how it will be handled.
Expression of Concern
The editor may publish an expression of concern when there is serious doubt about an article and an investigation has not yet been completed.
Retraction
An article is retracted when:
- its findings are unreliable because of a major error or misconduct (fabrication or falsification of data);
- it contains plagiarism;
- it was published elsewhere first without proper citation or permission (duplicate publication);
- it involves invalid or manipulated authorship; or
- it involves serious ethical violations, such as activities with community members carried out without their consent.
A retraction may be requested by the authors or decided by the editor. The retraction notice states the reason, who made the decision, and whether all authors agreed with it.
How notices are published
- Every erratum, corrigendum, expression of concern, and retraction is published as a separate, freely available notice, linked to the original article and its DOI, and updated in Crossref.
- A retracted article stays online, and its PDF is marked “RETRACTED” on every page, so that the scholarly record is preserved.
- A corrected article file may be replaced within one year of publication, with the date of correction shown on the article. After that, corrections are made only through a published notice.
Removal
An article is removed from the website only in rare cases, such as a legal violation or a serious risk to individuals. The bibliographic data and an explanation of the removal remain available.
Requests for correction, withdrawal, or retraction can be sent to swagati@amikom.ac.id.
All manuscripts submitted to SWAGATI: Journal of Community Service go through a double-blind peer review process: the identities of the authors and the reviewers are hidden from each other.
Review stages
- Initial screening. The editor checks that the manuscript fits the scope, follows the template, and has a Turnitin similarity score of 30% or below. Manuscripts that fail this check are returned to the authors or rejected.
- Peer review. Manuscripts that pass screening are sent to at least two reviewers with expertise in the subject. Reviewers assess originality, relevance to community service, method, results and impact, and the quality of writing and references. Reviewers are asked to complete the review within two weeks.
- Editorial decision. Based on the reviewers' reports, the editor makes one of the following decisions: Accept, Minor Revision, Major Revision, or Decline.
- Revision. Authors revise the manuscript and explain each change in a response to the reviewers. Revised manuscripts may be sent back to the reviewers.
- Final decision. The Editor-in-Chief makes the final decision on publication.
- Copyediting and layout. Accepted manuscripts are copyedited and typeset. Authors check and approve the galley proof before publication.
The whole process usually takes about 4–8 weeks from submission to decision. The reviewer comments and editorial decisions are confidential and are managed through the journal's OJS system.

